Frequently Asked Friday - Property Taxes • October 9, 2026

How Are Property Tax Assessments Calculated in Indiana – Part 2 of 5

Frequently Asked Friday: Let’s Talk Property Taxes
Part 2 of 5 — How Did They Come Up With THAT Assessment?

Last Friday, we started talking about property taxes—how they’re calculated and where the money goes.

Missed Part One? Start with our introduction to property taxes: https://toniderry.sites.erarealestate.com/2026/10/08/part-one-of-five-property-tax-discussion

This week, let’s tackle something nearly every homeowner has wondered:

“How in the world did they decide my house is worth THAT much?”

In Indiana, property assessments are based on something called market value-in-use

That’s the value of your property for the purpose it’s being used for. For a residential property, that means its value as a home.

But how do they arrive at that number?

Assessors consider factors such as square footage, age, construction quality, condition, improvements, land, and location.

Indiana also uses a process called annual trending

That means assessors study property sales in an area and use that information to determine whether assessed values need to be adjusted to reflect changes in the real estate market.

Here’s what surprises some homeowners:

Your assessed value can increase even if you haven’t changed a single thing about your house.

You haven’t remodeled the kitchen. You haven’t added a garage. You haven’t even painted the living room.

But if property values in your area have increased, your assessment may increase, too.

And the reverse can happen when market conditions change.

Now, let me put on my REALTOR® hat for a minute.

Your assessed value and what your home would actually sell for aren’t necessarily the same number.

Assessments use standardized valuation methods. An individual property’s selling price depends on what buyers are willing to pay for its particular features and condition.

We see this especially in our lake communities. Two homes can look similar on paper, but differences in frontage, water access, location, condition, and other features can make a substantial difference in what buyers will pay.

So, what if you think your assessment is wrong?

Here’s where you can do a little homework of your own.

Step 1: Look up your property.

For Kosciusko County, visit Beacon:

https://beacon.schneidercorp.com/

Select Indiana, then Kosciusko County. Search by your address, name, or parcel number.

Step 2: Find your property record card.

This is where you can review the information the assessor has about your property.

Look at the square footage, land details, buildings, improvements, and other recorded characteristics.

Is the information accurate?

Are you being assessed for something that doesn’t exist? Is the square footage wrong? Is an improvement incorrectly recorded?

Step 3: Compare your assessment with reality.

Ask yourself whether your property could reasonably have sold for approximately its assessed value as of the relevant assessment date.

Consider actual sales of similar properties, not just asking prices.

And remember, a neighbor’s property might not be as comparable as it first appears.

Step 4: Ask questions.

If something doesn’t look right, contact the Kosciusko County Assessor’s Office.

Phone: 574-372-2310

You can also visit the county’s website:

https://www.kosciusko.in.gov/

Sometimes a conversation and a review of your property record can help explain what you’re seeing.

Step 5: Know your appeal rights.

Indiana property owners have the right to challenge an assessment through a formal appeal process using Form 130.

But there are filing deadlines, and those deadlines depend on when the assessment notice was mailed.

For many assessments, the deadline is June 15, but don’t assume that date applies to your particular situation. Check your assessment notice and verify the applicable deadline with the assessor.

You can find official appeal information and forms through the Indiana Department of Local Government Finance:

https://www.in.gov/dlgf/

And one more thing: You do not have to hire an appraiser simply to file an assessment appeal. Supporting evidence matters, but Indiana does not require a formal appraisal to initiate the process.

Now, here’s something else worth understanding.

An increase in assessed value doesn’t necessarily mean your property tax bill will increase by the same percentage.

Tax rates, deductions, credits, and Indiana’s property-tax caps are also part of the equation.

And that brings us to next Friday.

Part 3: Deductions, Credits, and Property-Tax Caps — Are You Getting the Benefits You’re Entitled To?

My goal with this series isn’t to tell anyone whether property taxes are good, bad, too high, or too low.

It’s to help us understand how the system works so we can ask better questions and make informed decisions.

And if you start digging into your property information and find yourself overwhelmed, you’re welcome to reach out. I may not have every answer, but I’m happy to help you understand the real estate side and point you toward the right resources.

No politics. No telling you what to think.

Just information.

Your friend who happens to be a REALTOR®

Toni Derry, REALTOR® | ABR®
ERA Crossroads